Justice Barrett could save Biden student loan plan

Date:

[ad_1]

U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett.

Evelyn Hockstein | Reuters

The fate of the Biden administration’s sweeping plan to cancel $400 billion in student loan debt for tens of millions of Americans may hinge on the newest conservative member of the Supreme Court: Justice Amy Coney Barrett.

Barrett was the conservative justice who seemed the most unconvinced by the plaintiffs challenging student loan forgiveness, said Jed Shugerman, a law professor at Fordham University. Specifically, Shugerman said, Barrett didn’t seem to agree that they’d proven they have standing to sue.

“Barrett was vocally and deeply uncomfortable about ruling that any of the plaintiffs had standing,” Shugerman said.

More from Personal Finance:
Why Social Security retirement age, payroll tax may change
Experts argue Social Security retirement age shouldn’t pass 67
Return on waiting to claim Social Security is ‘huge’

As a rule, plaintiffs must prove that a policy would cause them injury in order to challenge it in the courts.

That requirement, which has long been defended by conservative justices, especially former Justice Antonin Scalia, is meant to avoid people using the legal system to fight policies they do not like or agree with.

The six GOP-led states that brought a lawsuit against President Joe Biden‘s plan argue that the debt cancellation for up to $20,000 per borrower would decrease profits for companies in their states that service federal student loans. That argument has become focused on the Missouri Higher Education Loan Authority, or MOHELA.

Nebraska’s solicitor general, James Campbell, who argued on behalf of the states in front of the justices on Feb. 28, said Biden’s plan threatened to eat away at MOHELA’s operating revenue by as much as 40%.

See also  Seeking Justice for Marshall and Millions of Dogs

Barrett seemingly unsatisfied by plaintiff arguments

Students prepare for loan repayment as the U.S. Supreme Court hears debt forgiveness case

But Barrett asked Campbell why MOHELA itself was not suing to block the plan instead of Missouri.

Officials at MOHELA recently said it had no involvement in Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt’s decision to sue against the program.

“Do you want to address why MOHELA’s not here?” Barrett asked.

Campbell replied, “MOHELA doesn’t need to be here because the state has the authority to speak for them.”

Barrett wasn’t satisfied by that answer.

“Why didn’t the state just make MOHELA come then?” she asked. “If MOHELA is really an arm of the state … why didn’t you just strong-arm MOHELA and say you’ve got to pursue this suit?”

Many commentators were asking, ‘Where is the Missouri SG?’ It’s like, Where’s Waldo?”

Jed Shugerman

law professor at Fordham University

Campbell answered: “Your honor, that’s a question of state politics.”

Shugerman, the law professor, said Campbell fumbled to explain how a loss in revenue for MOHELA would harm Missouri.

“The Nebraska solicitor general was unconvincing,” Shugerman said. “It was a mess.”

Shugerman also criticized the decision to have Nebraska’s top state attorney argue the case in front of the justices as opposed to the solicitor general of Missouri. He said that would have been appropriate because Missouri is the state with the best claim of an injury.

“Many commentators were asking, ‘Where is the Missouri SG?'” he said. “It’s like, ‘Where’s Waldo?'”

Plan’s survival depends on 2 conservative votes

Barrett alone can’t save the program.

See also  More Big Brands Brave the Rocky Terrain of Endorsement Deals With College Athletes

The liberal justices — Elena Kagan, Ketanji Brown Jackson and Sonia Sotomayor — are almost certain to vote in favor of the plan, Shugerman said.

On the other hand, three conservative justices, Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch and Samuel Alito are likely to vote against it, he said.

Because of that, the Biden administration will likely need to convince not just Barrett but at least one of the other two conservative members of the court, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh.

“If she is a fourth vote, the question is, can she convince a fifth?” Shugerman said.

If the justices ignore the states’ lack of standing, they risk allowing any state or individual to challenge almost any federal program, said Steven Schwinn, a law professor at the University of Illinois Chicago.

“This is no way to run a federal democracy,” Schwinn said. “If the plaintiffs have a problem with loan cancellation, they should take it up through political processes.”

[ad_2]

Source link

Popular Posts

More like this
Related

Boost Your Investment Portfolio with DSCR Rental Loans: Here’s How

In the competitive world of real estate investing, finding...

Is a Business Owners Policy Right for Your Business? Here’s What You Need to Know

Running a business comes with a host of responsibilities,...

How to Choose the Best Websites for Your Guest Posting Campaign

One of the main challenges of guest posting is...

How many days do you need to perform Umrah?

If you are performing Umrah for the first time...
Rahasia Main Mahjong Ways Terbukti Auto Maxwin Hari Ini Strategi Gates Of Olympus Paling Ampuh Bikin Cuan Cepat Bocoran Pola Gacor Mahjong Wins 3 Wajib Coba Rumus Ampuh Mahjong Ways Auto Menang Setiap Hari Cara Mudah Main Gates Of Olympus 100 Persen Berhasil Strategi Terbaik Hari Ini Di Mahjong Wins 3 Bikin Auto Maxwin Pola Mahjong Ways Paling Gacor 2025 Dijamin Menang Tips Main Gates Of Olympus Biar Mudah Maxwin Rumus Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Bisa Cuan Setiap Spin Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Pola Emas Anti Rungkad Strategi Paling Gacor Main Gates Of Olympus Hari Ini Rumus Mudah Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Wajib Tahu Bocoran Rahasia Mahjong Ways Yang Sudah Terbukti Cara Main Gates Of Olympus Paling Efektif Buat Maxwin Strategi Ampuh Main Mahjong Wins 3 Auto Profit Rahasia Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Buat Maxwin Teknik Mudah Menang Gates Of Olympus 2025 Pola Pasti Cuan Di Mahjong Wins 3 Scatter Hitam Tips Dan Trik Ajaib Menang Mahjong Ways Rumus Anti Rugi Main Gates Of Olympus Strategi Pasti Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Hari Ini Cara Gampang Maxwin Di Mahjong Ways Tanpa Modal Besar Pola Terbaik Gates Of Olympus Biar Auto Jackpot Rumus Rahasia Mudah Menang Di Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi Terupdate Main Mahjong Ways Hari Ini Cara Main Gates Of Olympus Yang Bikin Dominasi Spin Bocoran Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Gacor Trik Mudah Cuan Di Mahjong Ways Di Tahun 2025 Strategi Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Anti Kalah Rumus Cuan Mahjong Wins 3 Buktikan Sendiri Teknik Baru Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Winrate Tinggi Cara Paling Mudah Maxwin Di Gates Of Olympus Tips Strategi Pasti Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Pola Gates Of Olympus Biar Spin Ga Berhenti Bocoran Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Auto Cuan Strategi Main Mahjong Ways Dijamin Maxwin Rumus Spesial Main Gates Of Olympus Hari Ini Cara Main Mahjong Wins 3 Buat Pemula Auto Menang Tips Dan Pola Main Mahjong Ways Anti Rugi Rahasia Cara Main Gates Of Olympus 2025 Biar Profit Main Game Mahjong Ways Dengan Strategi Terbaik Hari Ini Gates Of Olympus Pola Gacor Terbaru Untuk Maxwin Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Rumus Ampuh Untuk Menang Besar Strategi Hari Ini Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Mudah Menang Di Gates Of Olympus Dengan Pola Terbaik Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Mudah Maxwin Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Mahjong Ways 2025 Gates Of Olympus Strategi Ampuh Untuk Kemenangan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Cara Main Dengan Baik Dan Mudah Menang Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Maxwin Setiap Hari Rumus Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Raih Jackpot Dengan Mudah Strategi Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Buat Cuan Tanpa Henti Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Dan Mudah Maxwin Mudah Menang Gates Of Olympus Dengan Rumus Teruji Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Di Mahjong Wins 3 Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Gates Of Olympus Di Tahun 2025 Mahjong Ways Pola Gacor Terbaru Untuk Menang Besar Gates Of Olympus Strategi Hari Ini Buat Maxwin Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Cara Main Dengan Baik Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Kemenangan Konsisten Rumus Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Buat Cuan Cepat Strategi Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Untuk Pemula Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Untuk Maxwin Mudah Menang Gates Of Olympus Dengan Pola Efektif Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Untuk Pemula Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Anda Gates Of Olympus Pola Gacor Hari Ini Untuk Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi Ampuh Untuk Kemenangan Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Buat Cuan Tiap Hari Rumus Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Untuk Maxwin Strategi Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Buat Pemula Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Dan Benar Mudah Menang Gates Of Olympus Dengan Strategi Terbaru Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Untuk Anda Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Gates Of Olympus Mahjong Ways Pola Gacor Terbaru Untuk Cuan Gates Of Olympus Strategi Hari Ini Untuk Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Cara Main Dengan Baik Untuk Pemula Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Kemenangan Besar Rumus Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Untuk Cuan Maksimal Main Game Mahjong Ways Dengan Strategi Terbaik Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Rumus Ampuh Untuk Menang Besar Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Rumus Ampuh Untuk Menang Besar Strategi Hari Ini Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Mudah Menang Di Gates Of Olympus Dengan Pola Terbaik Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Mudah Maxwin Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Mahjong Ways 2025 Gates Of Olympus Strategi Ampuh Untuk Kemenangan Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Cara Main Dengan Baik Dan Mudah Menang Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Maxwin Setiap Hari Rumus Ampuh Gates Of Olympus Raih Jackpot Dengan Mudah Strategi Hari Ini Mahjong Wins 3 Buat Cuan Tanpa Henti Cara Main Mahjong Ways Dengan Baik Dan Mudah Maxwin Mudah Menang Gates Of Olympus Dengan Rumus Teruji Petualangan Cuan Hari Ini Di Mahjong Wins 3 Penghasil Saldo Dana Terbaik Gates Of Olympus 2025 Mahjong Ways Pola Gacor Terbaru Untuk Menang Besar Gates Of Olympus Strategi Hari Ini Buat Maxwin Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Cara Main Dengan Baik Pola Terbaik Mahjong Ways Untuk Kemenangan Konsisten Bocoran Pola Mahjong Ways Hari Ini Dari Mawar500 Cara Bermain Mahjong Ways Untuk Pemula Dijamin Gacor Rumus Rahasia Mahjong Ways Versi Mawar500 Yang Wajib Kamu Coba Pola Terbaru Starlight Princess Dan Mahjong Ways Bikin Auto Jp Seseorang Berhasil Menang 30 Juta Di Mahjong Ways Berkat Trik Mawar500 Tips Trik Mahjong Ways Ala Mawar500 Bikin Cuan Tiap Hari Pola Mahjong Ways Paling Gacor Berdasarkan Analisa Starlight Princess Trik Main Mahjong Ways Modal Receh Bisa Menang Puluhan Juta Bocoran Starlight Princess Dan Mahjong Ways Hari Ini Dijamin Kena Rahasia Rumus Mahjong Ways Agar Selalu Maxwin Versi Mawar500